by Purusoth Reddy
Oct 30, 2024

Stainless Steel vs. Nonstick

Stainless Steel vs. Nonstick Cookware- Which is Better for Your Kitchen?

The cookware you choose plays a crucial role in both your cooking experience and the quality of the final dish.

The debate between stainless steel cookware and nonstick, two of the most popular types, brings both pros and cons, depending on what you want to cook and personal preference.

In this article, we examine the differences between stainless steel cookware vs nonstick, their performance, health implications, and durability, and which of the two might better serve your kitchen.

What are Stainless Steel and Non-stick Cookware?

1. Stainless steel cookware is an alloy of metals, which includes three-quarters steel, chromium, and sometimes nickel. Do you know: What is the role of nickel in stainless steel cookware? It is generally famous for its durability, heat resistance, and non-reactive attributes.

Professional chefs prefer stainless steel pans because they perform well under high heat and help achieve a perfect golden color on food.

2. Nonstick cookware features a nonstick layer, often made from Teflon (PFOA-free since 2013) or ceramic. While ceramic is considered safer and more eco-friendly, it typically wears out faster than Teflon.

Nonstick cookware gained popularity in home kitchens more than stainless steel, mainly because of its easy usage.

Difference Between Nonstick and Stainless Steel Cookware

When choosing between stainless steel and nonstick cookware, several factors should be considered. These include cooking performance, durability, ease of maintenance, and health considerations.

1. Cooking Performance

Choosing stainless steel over nonstick or vice versa results in a huge difference in cooking performance, primarily in heat distribution and versatility.

Here’s stainless steel vs non stick — from cooking point of view.

Stainless steel pans brown and caramelise perfectly and are easy to deglaze. Their thermal conductivity is excellent, and they can reach enough temperatures without damaging, which makes them ideal for activities such as searing steaks or caramelising onions. They do require proper preheating and a bit of oil so that food does not stick to the pan.
Because of their non-stick coating, Non-stick pans are great for low—to medium-heat cooking. They're very good at cooking light foods, such as pancakes, eggs, and, of course, fish. Non-stick cookware does not do very well with high-heat cooking since the topping is designed to break off gradually over time, which negatively impacts its ability to cook.

Triply pans are indeed the best of both worlds in terms of durability and cooking performance. featuring three layers: an aluminum core for heat distribution, sandwiched between layers of stainless steel for durability. Check out triply vs stainless steel to know more.

2. Health Related Issues

Stainless steel vs non stick — from health pov is very crucial to consider.

The health benefits of stainless steel cookware are significant. Because stainless steel has no coating, harmful chemicals won’t leach into your food. However, people with nickel allergies may need to be cautious when using stainless steel containing nickel. Also, it is non-reactive, meaning that it will not interact with acidic or alkaline foods, making it safe for all styles of cooking.
While nonstick cookware, especially when coated with Teflon, can be toxic if overheated beyond 500°F, modern nonstick coatings are considered safe under normal cooking temperatures. However, they are more prone to wear and tear and eventually break the coating over time. Ceramic nonstick cookware contains no PTFE or PFOA but wears out fast compared with Teflon.

3. Durability and Longevity

Stainless steel vs non stick — how long will it last? Is the dilemma over yet?

Stainless steel cookware is known for its longevity. A good stainless pan, properly cared for, can last for many decades. It resists rust, scratching, and denting and can withstand high-heat cooking, making stainless steel a durable cooker for many daily uses. Regarding durability, check cast iron vs stainless steel as well.
Nonstick cookware typically lasts 1 to 5 years, depending on its quality and usage. Using metal utensils or exposing the pan to high heat can significantly shorten its lifespan, with ceramic nonstick coatings wearing out faster than Teflon. Nonstick coatings are prone to scratches and degradation over time. For instance, the use of metal utensils and high temperatures may degrade the coating. If the coating has reached its exhaustion, that means it has lost its nonstick features; then it will stick. The pans will not cook food evenly.

4. Cleaning and Maintenance

Stainless steel vs non stick — which is more easy to clean? Lets see.

Generally, when evaluating stainless steel pans vs nonstick, rating by aspect would state that nonstick cookware has the advantage in the ease of cleaning.

The bestselling point of nonstick coating is that food can't stick to its surface, and, therefore, getting rid of residues is easy and fast —almost always short work with a sponge.
Stainless steel, on the other hand, is much more abrasive to clean after use, especially if food is stuck to it. However, once you heat the pan and add just the right quantity of oil, you won't experience any sticking problems.

You can scrub stainless steel very roughly without breaking it, whereas with nonstick pans, you have to be very delicate when cleaning it. Here’s how to remove rust from stainless steel.

5. Cost and Value

Stainless steel vs non stick — which is worthy of an investment?

Stainless steel cookware is a bit more expensive to buy but holds better long-term value because you will probably have to replace it much fewer times than you would with a non-stick pan. So, by paying the extra cash for a high-quality stainless steel set, you are saving money in the long run.
Nonstick cookware is less expensive, but when you must replace it entirely every few years, the costs can multiply rather easily. You may save money in the short term, but replacing those non-stick pans over and over again can really increase their expenses long term.

6. Environmental Impact

Stainless steel vs non stick — which is more greener?

Stainless steel is more environmentally friendly because it is fully recyclable, thus meaning that it has a much longer service life to reduce the need for constant replacement. Also, stainless steel is made from purely natural materials, and when it is discarded, it can be reused again without generating any form of waste product.
Nonstick cookware is less environmentally friendly because it uses chemical coatings in its production. Even during manufacture, it may emit several dangerous emissions, and once the nonstick coating wears off, the cookware has to be sent to a landfill. Ceramic nonstick is a more eco-friendly alternative to Teflon, though it still falls short of stainless steel's sustainability

7. User Experience

Stainless steel vs non stick — who will be your BFF?

Nonstick cookware is far more user-friendly for those without much cooking experience or who simply prefer the easier route. The pan doesn't require lots of oil to cook with, and food release is rather easy. Nonstick pans are best for people who wish to cook something with ease and less mess.
However, for advanced cooking techniques or pro results, many cooks prefer stainless steel. It delivers improved heat control and allows deglazing, which creates rich sauces from browned food. It is also much more versatile for different types of cooking.

Stainless Steel Cookware vs Nonstick

Let's break this down a little clearer between stainless steel cookware vs nonstick.

Heat Tolerance: Nonstick pans are good at handling limited high heat, but stainless steel can withstand a lot of high-temperature exposure.
Cooking Versatility: Stainless is recommended for searing, browning, and deglazing. Nonstick pans are good for delicate fare such as eggs or pancakes.
Maintenance: In terms of maintenance, nonstick may be less of a hassle, but stainless steel requires more care in cleaning but offers more durability in return.
Health Considerations: Stainless steel does not chemically react to any food, whether cooked, acidic, or salty, and is perfectly safe with all types of foods. Nonstick pans, especially Teflon-coated nonstick pans, might emit toxic fumes if overheated.

You can also read about the difference between hybrid and non stick cookware here.

Pros and Cons of Cooking with Stainless steel cookware vs nonstick

Feature	Stainless Steel	Nonstick
Heat Resistance	Resistant to high heat, oven-safe	Ideal for low to medium-heat
Durability	It lasts for decades. They are very long-lasting	Sensitive to scratches and short lifespan
Health Concerns	Non-reactive, safe for all foods	Teflon may give off fumes at high heat
Ease of Cleaning	Can require scrubbing	Very easy to clean
Versatility	Extremely good for browning, searing, deglazing	Very good for delicate foods
Cost	High in the first instance but durable for a longer time frame	Low but tends to be replaced more often
Environmental Impact	Fully recyclable, long-lasting	Chemical coatings and more frequent replacements

Similarities Between Stainless steel cookware vs nonstick

Even though stainless steel and nonstick cookware differ from each other on so many counts, there are some similarities too:

Available in various sizes and designs according to different cooking requirements.
It is compatible with any stovetop, including gas, electric, and induction (the base type depends on the cookware).
Both stainless steel and nonstick come in ergonomic handles and lids for ease and convenience. You can also have a look at the Stahl Cookware Sizing Guide.

FAQs

Q1. Is it better to get stainless steel or nonstick?

Ans. It depends on your needs, first understand the distinctions of stainless steel cookware vs nonstick.

Stainless steel is preferable for high-heat cooking, durability, and versatility, while nonstick is recommended for delicate food cooking and easier cleanup.

Q2. Do chefs use non stick or stainless steel?

Ans. Professional cooks normally prefer stainless steel because of its tough heat tolerance, durability, and versatility in various techniques, such as searing and deglazing.

Q3. What is the healthiest type of cookware to use?

Ans. Stainless steel is probably the healthiest as it does not react and does not produce harmful chemicals in food. You can also read about types of cookware here

Q4. Which cooker is best, non-stick or stainless steel?

Ans. If you prefer easy cleaning up, low—to medium-temperature cooked food is best suited for nonstick. However, if you want versatility, durability, and high-temperature cooking, stainless steel is the better choice.

Q5. What are the disadvantages of stainless steel cookware?

Ans. In stainless steel cookware vs nonstick, the former dips in performance due to its weight and price. However, Triply pans are the best way out from this disadvantage.

Stainless steel cookware is more challenging to clean when food sticks and requires a drop of oil to prevent sticking. It is also heavier and more expensive in the short term.

Q6. Which coating is best for cookware?

Ans. If you like nonstick cookware, choose a PFOA-free Teflon or ceramic coating for a safer and friendlier option for the environment.

My shopping cart

Stainless Steel vs. Nonstick